Leonie Haimson of Class Size Matters, along with a burgeoning list of supporters signing on, writes Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Joel Klein
Context:
Ps 109 in E. Harlem; after a FOIL request
by Gwen Goodwin, we found out that the school is being sold by DOE for $1 to be
made into artists lofts;
Klein argues 1- that they’re
building new schools in the community, which isn’t true – there is
not a single school in the capital plan for the area;
2- that there is no need for more schools,
which is untrue, given local elementary schools are full and also 75% of NYC HS
students attend overcrowded schools, and can attend anywhere near public
transportation, which this is.
3- that it would be cheaper to build a new
school than to renovate this building into a HS, which is also not true.
Call me for more or Gwen
Goodwin at 212-534-0963 or Eugenia Simmons-Taylor, president of
the Presidents Council in D4 at (212) 666-1751
You can also go to www.saveps109.com
for more info; I include a letter about this below.
Leonie Haimson
Class Size Matters
124 Waverly Pl.
New York, NY 10011
212-674-7320
leonie@att.net
www.classsizematters.org
July 20, 2006
Dear Mayor Bloomberg and Chancellor Klein:
As parents, educators and advocates who understand the overriding need to
eliminate overcrowding in our schools and reduce class size, we strongly
support the efforts to save PS 109 in East Harlem
as a school rather than give the building away to developers.
According to the Coalition to Save PS 109, this building could be used to
provide 1,200 seats for our children rather than 64 artist lofts. The Community
Education Council for District 4 has voted that this school should be included
in the capital plan and returned to the community as a school.
The schools in the district are already overcrowded. In a survey done by the
East Harlem Coalition, chaired by Reverend Norm Eddy, 82% of District 4
principals reported that space was a serious problem in their schools. In fact,
nearby PS 72 is so overcrowded it has to lease space for an annex in a former
school building, now privately owned, after the building was sold by the Board
of Education in the 1980's. And yet, according to the Department of Education,
there are no new schools in the capital plan to be built in the district over
the next five years.
Moreover, whatever the situation in the district's elementary schools, our high
school students can travel anywhere near public transportation and 75% of them
currently attend overcrowded schools. P.S. 109 could be the site of a new major
high school or two new small high schools, thus relieving the pressure on
other, already overcrowded high schools. Another feasible use of the P.S.109
building would be to allow for the expansion of the full-day pre-K initiative
recently approved by you and the City Council.
All of these uses would be particularly apt for a neighborhood characterized by
a young, growing and under-served immigrant community.
In fact, since education is your stated top priority, we urge you to adopt the
following principle: until every child in our city attends an uncrowded school
with smaller classes, no NYC school building should be sold or given
away to be used for other purposes.
Yours sincerely,
Eugenia Simmons-Taylor, President of President's Council, District 4
Leonie Haimson, Class Size Matters
Luis O. Reyes, Ph.D
Barbara A. Grant, River East Parent's Association, District 4
Randi Weingarten, President, United Federation of Teachers
Gwen Goodwin, The Coalition to Save PS 109
Edward Henry, East Harlem resident, voter and
taxpayer
Tim Johnson, Chairman, Chancellor's Parent Advisory Council (CPAC)
Donald Reddick, Parent PS 83 District 4
Elender Foxe, PTA PS 171, District 4 PC, CPAC Recording Secretary
Bill Lynch, President, Bill Lynch Associates
Charles Jordan, President- United Parents Association
Martha Cid, Manhattan
resident, voter and taxpayer
Rev Norm Eddy, Chair of The East Harlem Coalition to Improve our Public Schools
Angela & Giles Smith, Parents of 5 children in District 4
Diana Marenfeld, Citywide Council for Special Education
Servia Silva, UFT District 4 representative
Tina Reed, Parent of two children in District 4
Hon. Lisa A. Pressley, Assoc. District Leader 68th AD West
Aida Pagan, Treasurer- District 4 Presidents' Council
Carlton Evans, PTA President- CPEMS District 4
Thomas L. Vance, Jr., Parent of two children in District 4
Corinna Lindenberg, EarthSchool PA, District 1 PC, CPAC Corresponding Secretary
Betsy Combier, Editor- Parent Advocates
Cecilia Blewer, ICOPE
Dawn Thomas, Parent of two children in District 4
David Wolfson, public school parent and New
York City taxpayer
Norman Scott, The Independent Community of Educators & Education Notes
Carolyn M. Birden, Elected Representative, WBAI Local Station Board
Alicia Goudie, East Harlem Resident, voter and taxpayer
Dakota Russell, Student, Class Size Matters
John M. Beam, Executive Director, National
Center for Schools and Communities, Fordham University
Leticia Perez, Parent District 4
Barry Weinbrom- Director After School Activity Programs
Diane O'Donnell, District 31 Parent of a student attending a HS at 167%
capacity
Manuel Castro, Lead Organizer, Latin American Integration Center
Olga Mendez, Former
State Senator
Juliet Luther, Bilingual Educator/ESL Specialist
Steven G. Ungar, former public school parent
Randy Wgman, parent, District 31
Anthony C. Romeo, parent, IS 89
Karen V. Romeo, PTA Exec. Bd., IS 89
Julius Dixson, Jr
Susan Crawford, The Right to Read Project, D-3 parent
Shelley Grant, teacher, P.S. 51
Rocco Rella, District 15, parent
Guy de Baere, public school parent
Lynne Glasner, M.A., educational consultant
Robin Moore, parent District 3
Robert Schwartz-Parent, PS 75 District 3
Josephine Wan, District 2 Parent
Lesley Halliday, Parent
Yvonne Spivack, Parent of student at I.C.E.
Marshall Berman, Distinguished Professor CCNY/CUNY
Shellie Sclan, Parent, MS 54 Manhattan
David Demnitz, Parent, PS 6, Teacher
Deborah Kaufmann, I.C.E. Parent
Lori A. Bores, Vice-President PTA P.S. 6
Victoria Dallas-Stephenson, Muscota New School
Judy O'Brien, District 15 Parent and Educator
Debbie Fine, teacher PS 79Q District 25
Lorraine Levey, PTA Executive Board Member P.S. 183 District 2
Dilsia Pena, Learning Leader-volunteer
Walter Goodman parent of 2 children, one at LaGuardia HS and one in special
ed
Fariba Behnegar, PS166 parent
Majid Nassiri, PS166 parent
Vicki Madden, parent of students at Brooklyn New School and Beacon High School
Teri Schlesinger, Parent of three children in District 25, District 30 and
District 2
Sandy Wavrick, Parent, District 15/Region 8
Sandra Stratton -Gonzalez, Parent and Dance Educator
Mary van Valkenburg, PTA Budget Officer, Bard HS Early College
Valarie Bennett, Parent, District 3, MS 54
Gabriella Gruder-Poni, Advantage Testing
Diana O'Brien, District 2 Representative, and parent of 2, one in a class of 27
Ronnie Malandrakis, Parent Coordinator - PS107Q
Emily Fano, G & T Parent, PS 166
J Napoli, Teacher D30
John M. Wetherhold and Xu Zi parents of Sherley in middle school district
2
Isaac Carmignani, Past Co-President PS122Q, Parent, Treasurer D30 President's
Council
Leticia Padro
Deirdre Fisher-Kemp, Parent / Project Manager, NYS Affordable Housing
Corporation
Paula Rogovin, Teacher, 33 years, The Manhattan New School
Rachel R Rachel List, District 1 parent
Bonnie Maitenaz, Parent, PS 41
John & Judy Bresnahan, Parents, District 2, PS 41 & MS 255
Roseann Marcus - Parent and PTA Representative - Talent Unlimited H.S.
Marian Trupiano Former CPAC Representative District 15
Autumn Lucas, BASE
High School
Ruth Lilienstein-Gatton, parent, District 6
Leslie Salzman, Brooklyn parent with children attending public schools in
Brooklyn and Manhattan
Bernadette Knox Parent Manhattan
Julia Crislip, Parent District 2
Pamela Wheaton, Advocates for Children
Mary McGregor, Treasurer, SLT, PAC of IS/PS 165
Karin P.E. Gustafson, parent of child in Manhattan public school
Joan O'Mahoney, Teacher, parent and Learning Leader Brooklyn, Region 6
CC: Speaker Christine Quinn,
Comptroller William C. Thompson, Councilmember Robert Jackson, Councilmember
Melissa Mark Viverito, Speaker Sheldon Silver, Assemblymember Cathy Nolan,
State Senator Jose M. Serrano, Assemblymember Adam Clayton Powell IV, Community
Board 11, Congressman Charles Rangel, and Manhattan Borough President Scott
Stringer
More Context:
What's happening in the Bronx
Sources say that chronically overcrowded
conditions in high schools in the Bronx are even worse than usual this fall; Ken nedy HS supposed to be limited to 1700 students
this year; instead they have over 3000 students, for only 62 classrooms.
Students who start early in the morning are being told to stay until 4:30
to get the credits they need to graduate. Unlikely that many will.
Situation exacerbated because population
is still growing while grades are being added to many of the small schools,
taking up more room inside of overcrowded buildings. Evander Childs,
which is being phased out with 5 or 6 other schools in the building, now has
800-900 kids assigned to lunch in one period in the cafeteria.
Clinton HS at 4700 expecting more OTC's,
even some of the new small schools are getting flooded; Law & Community
Service was forced to take 153, instead of 108 in entering class.
At Walton, the remaining students are
being squeezed into classrooms in disrepair, including classrooms in basement
rooms w/ no ventilation in awful conditions.
And yet DOE is selling a perfectly good
school for $1 because it is not needed, to be used as artist housing.
Leonie Haimson
Class Size Matters
124 Waverly Pl.
New York, NY 10011
212-674-7320
leonie@att.net
www.classsizematters.org
|